M&S’s beloved strawberry sandwich is back — with a major change shoppers say is ‘deranged’
M&S’s Beloved Strawberry Sandwich Returns — But With a Controversial Twist
M S s beloved strawberry sandwich - A year has passed since M&S sparked a frenzy among shoppers with the launch of its Red Diamond Strawberry & Creme Sandwich. The sweet treat quickly became a sensation, with over 75,000 units sold in just five days. Its Japanese-inspired design and unique combination of flavors drew widespread attention, making it a standout item in the retailer’s lineup. However, the original version’s popularity has now been challenged by a new iteration that has divided opinions.
The Original’s Resurgence
When the Red Diamond Sandwich first hit shelves in June 2025, it was hailed as a fresh take on the classic strawberry and cream pairing. The sandwich featured soft, sweetened bread, a generous amount of whipped cream cheese, and the UK’s sweetest strawberries, which reportedly retained their shape despite sitting in the creamy filling. For many, it was a quirky, fun addition to their lunch or dessert options. Yet, despite its charm, some felt it lacked the depth of a traditional cake or pastry, leading to mixed reviews.
A New Twist on Tradition
Now, M&S has reintroduced the iconic sandwich but with a bold new version: the Chocolate, Strawberry & Pistachio Creme Sandwich. This update swaps the original’s whipped cream for a more complex combination of cocoa-enriched bread, pistachio creme, and a rich layer of Fairtrade Belgian dark chocolate sauce. The change has left customers both intrigued and exasperated. While some praise its innovative flavor profile, others argue it strays too far from the original’s simplicity, calling it “deranged” and “grim” in appearance.
Shoppers have been quick to share their thoughts online. User @misslondoncy exclaimed, “Lord, have mercy!” after seeing the new creation on Instagram. Meanwhile, @milo_mimi_and_me described it as “divine,” while @half_cut_dining joked, “Omg the pistachio range will be the death of me.” These reactions highlight the polarizing nature of the update, with fans of the original expressing disappointment while others eagerly embrace the change.
The Debate Over Innovation
The return of the sandwich has reignited conversations about what makes a product successful. Critics claim the chocolate version is “wrong on every level,” accusing M&S of overcomplicating a simple recipe. They argue that the addition of pistachio and chocolate transforms the treat into something unrecognizable, sacrificing the nostalgic charm of the original. Meanwhile, supporters believe the new iteration offers a refreshing take, blending unexpected flavors in a way that appeals to modern tastes.
Despite the divided opinions, the new product has generated significant demand. Its limited availability has turned it into a highly sought-after item, with queues forming at stores and social media buzz continuing to grow. M&S’s strategy of reintroducing a beloved item with a twist appears to be working, even if it’s not without controversy. The company’s ability to create a viral sensation once again underscores its knack for capturing public interest through creative product designs.
Complementary Offerings
To accompany the sandwiches, M&S has also launched two new dips. The Strawberry & Cream Dip (£3.25) combines whipped cream, full-fat soft cheese, and natural Greek-style yogurt, layered with strawberry compote. For chocolate lovers, the Chocolate and Pistachio Dip (£3.75) features an Italian and Belgian chocolate ganache, mixed with pistachio creme and topped with crushed pistachio pieces. These additions provide extra options for those looking to enjoy the same nostalgic flavors in a different format.
A Personal Perspective
As someone who sampled the original Red Diamond Sandwich in June 2025, I found it to be an enjoyable novelty but not a groundbreaking creation. While the soft bread and creamy filling were pleasant, the idea of a sandwich as a dessert felt slightly unconventional. My criticism at the time was that I kept hoping it could be a cake instead, which might have been a better fit for the flavor combination.
“Though it’s a fun twist on the classic summer pairing, I wasn’t blown away by it. The bread is soft and sweet, and the strawberries add a nice pop of color. However, I kept wishing it could be a cake rather than a sandwich.”
Now, with the chocolate version, the divide has only grown. The new sandwich’s layered flavors and richer texture are more ambitious, but they also feel like a departure from the original’s charm. While I acknowledge the effort to innovate, I’m still not convinced that this version is a must-buy. For some, it’s a triumph; for others, it’s a gamble that may not pay off.
Nevertheless, the return of the Red Diamond Sandwich demonstrates M&S’s ability to adapt to consumer trends. By leveraging social media and creating a product that sparks conversation, the retailer has once again managed to generate buzz. Whether this latest iteration is a success or a misstep remains to be seen, but its availability for a limited time ensures that the debate will continue for weeks.
Stay Updated with Metro Food
At Metro Food, we bring you the latest in culinary trends, recipes, and restaurant reviews. If you’re looking for news on everything from new sandwich flavors to secret menu items, you’re in the right place. Don’t miss out on our stories — click the button below and tick Metro.co.uk to ensure our articles appear first in your Google search results.
From the latest Walkers flavor innovations to the hidden gems of the McDonald’s menu, Metro Food covers all the essentials. Our team is committed to delivering content that keeps you informed and inspired, whether you’re a seasoned foodie or a casual eater. Join our community and never miss the latest updates on your favorite topics.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Your information will be used in line with our Privacy Policy.
As the demand for the new sandwiches grows, it’s clear that M&S continues to play a pivotal role in shaping the UK’s food landscape. While the chocolate version may not satisfy everyone, it has undeniably reignited interest in the product, proving that even the smallest changes can create major ripples in the market.