AMP Article

Thomas Tuchel told to axe ‘struggling’ England star from World Cup team

Published June 17, 2026 · Updated June 17, 2026 · By Daniel Martinez

Thomas Tuchel Told to Drop 'Struggling' England Star from World Cup Squad

Thomas Tuchel told to axe struggling - As England prepares to launch their World Cup campaign, head coach Thomas Tuchel faces mounting pressure to reconsider the inclusion of Bukayo Saka in the squad. The Arsenal forward, once a key figure in the team’s attacking arsenal, is now reportedly under scrutiny due to concerns over his recent performance. According to insiders, Saka’s ability to make a significant impact has diminished, leading some to suggest he might be axed from the starting XI for the opening match against Croatia.

Confirmed Squad Members and Strategic Challenges

Tuchel has already secured several players for his World Cup roster, with goalkeeper Jordan Pickford, left-back Nico O’Reilly, and midfielder Declan Rice appearing as near-certainties. Striker Harry Kane, the team’s captain, is also expected to feature prominently, despite the need to balance his role with other attacking options. However, the manager’s task is far from straightforward, particularly in the center-back and wide positions.

The center-back duo will likely consist of John Stones and Ezri Konsa, a pairing that has drawn criticism from former England stars. Marc Guehi, a rising talent, is currently in the squad, and some veterans argue that his inclusion could provide a more dynamic defensive presence. Meanwhile, on the wings, the decision to favor Anthony Gordon over Marcus Rashford on the left has sparked debate, with Jude Bellingham set to anchor the No. 10 role ahead of Morgan Rogers.

Saka’s Role in Question

Saka’s position as England’s primary right-winger has been a topic of discussion for years, but recent challenges have cast doubt on his readiness for the tournament. Despite his individual brilliance at Arsenal, the forward has struggled to maintain consistency this season, particularly in high-stakes matches. His performance in the Champions League final, where he was visibly overwhelmed, has been cited as a turning point in the debate over his inclusion.

With Croatia as the opening opponents, Tuchel may opt for a fresh face on the wing. Noni Madueke, Saka’s Arsenal teammate, is seen as a viable alternative, especially given his emerging form and versatility. This decision could signal a shift in the manager’s approach, prioritizing squad balance over past loyalties. However, Saka’s departure would leave a void in England’s attacking options, requiring careful planning to mitigate potential weaknesses.

Expert Opinions on the Squad Decision

"I think Bukayo Saka has had a tough season, and his performance in the Champions League final showed he’s not at his best. For me, he’s not the player who should start in a World Cup opener," said Emmanuel Petit, a former Arsenal and Chelsea midfielder, in a talkSPORT interview. "There are other players who are more reliable right now. While I’m a huge fan of Saka, I have to be honest—he doesn’t quite meet the standard of a top-tier World Cup player."

Petit’s comments highlight a growing consensus among experts that Saka’s recent form falls short of the demands of international competition. The French World Cup winner emphasized that players like Saka must consistently deliver under pressure, a criterion he believes has not been met. "Even at 60 per cent, they should be on the pitch," he added. "Saka isn’t that kind of player. The squad has so many stronger options that deserve a starting spot."

Other voices in the football community have echoed similar sentiments. Former Three Lions legend John Barnes, known for his insightful tactical analysis, offered a balanced perspective on the opening fixture. "I’m predicting a 1-1 draw," Barnes told Betfred. "Both teams will be cautious, and Croatia’s ability to perform beyond their expectations in past tournaments makes them a tough opponent. England needs to start strong, but so does Croatia, and this match could be a deciding factor for both."

Barnes also noted that the choice of Croatia as England’s first game is strategic. "It’s essential for England to avoid a shocking start, but the same applies to Croatia. This is the hardest match in the group, and it might work in England’s favor," he explained. "Teams that should be beaten often feel overconfident, which can create unexpected challenges. I’m confident they’ll advance, but I’m glad it’s Croatia rather than a more intimidating opponent."

Croatia’s Tournament History and England’s Challenges

Croatia’s recent history in the World Cup serves as a reminder of their ability to compete at the highest level. In 2018, they reached the final, defeating England in the semifinals on a dramatic penalty shootout. Their resilience and tactical discipline have made them a formidable team, even against stronger squads. This matchup against England could test Tuchel’s ability to adapt his tactics, particularly with the need to secure a positive result without overcomplicating the lineup.

Tuchel’s team will face the next two group games against Ghana and Panama, but the first match against Croatia is critical. A win or draw here could boost confidence and set the tone for the rest of the campaign. However, a loss might create pressure to overhaul the squad before the next fixtures. The manager’s reputation for pragmatism suggests he will focus on maximizing strengths while addressing key vulnerabilities, such as the right wing.

Broader Implications for England’s Campaign

The decision to drop Saka from the starting XI reflects the high stakes of the World Cup and the need to optimize every position. While some fans may lament the move, others see it as a necessary step to ensure England’s chances of success. The squad’s depth and quality mean that alternatives like Madueke can be considered, though the manager must weigh the risks of untested players against the benefits of fresh energy.

Tuchel’s selection process also highlights the ongoing evolution of England’s team under his guidance. Players like Gordon and Bellingham are expected to fill gaps, but their performances will be crucial in proving their worth. The manager’s trust in these emerging talents could determine whether England’s World Cup campaign remains on track or faces early hurdles. As the Three Lions prepare for their first match, the pressure is on to deliver a statement performance that aligns with the team’s ambitious goals.

With the World Cup drawing closer, the focus remains on the opening fixture and the decisions that will shape England’s path. Tuchel’s choices will be scrutinized not only for their immediate impact but also for their long-term implications. Whether Saka’s exclusion is a bold move or a tactical misstep will depend on how the team performs in the first few matches. For now, the anticipation is high, and the stage is set for a thrilling campaign.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Your information will be used in line with our Privacy Policy.