Why Marc Guehi has been left out of England team facing Croatia
Why Marc Guehi has been left – England’s squad for their World Cup opener against Croatia has sparked debate among fans and analysts, with Manchester City’s Marc Guehi missing out on a starting spot despite his recent form. The 25-year-old center-back, who had been a key figure in the Three Lions’ Euro 2024 campaign, was sidelined for the tournament’s opening match due to a suspension. However, his absence from the starting XI has raised questions about his current role in the team under new manager Thomas Tuchel.
Guehi’s contributions to the national team during Euro 2024 were significant, as he played in all but one of the tournament matches. His only miss came during the decisive win over Switzerland, where a yellow card forced him to sit out. Since then, the player has returned to form with Crystal Palace and Manchester City, winning back-to-back FA Cup finals. His performances have earned him a reputation as a reliable and adaptable defender, leading to expectations that he would be a consistent starter in this summer’s World Cup.
Tuchel’s Strategic Shift
Despite his recent success, Guehi has been omitted from the lineup for Croatia, with Tuchel opting for a different defensive approach. The decision echoes his choice in a previous friendly match against Costa Rica, where he paired John Stones and Ezri Konsa in the center of defense. This selection has drawn attention, as both Stones and Konsa bring contrasting strengths to the backline. Stones, the veteran defender, is known for his physicality and composure, while Konsa, a younger player, offers pace and versatility.
Tuchel’s preference for Stones and Konsa is rooted in their ability to provide stability and adaptability. Stones, in particular, has been a central figure in the England squad, having participated in six major international tournaments. His experience, combined with his leadership qualities, makes him a trusted asset for Tuchel. However, the 32-year-old has faced challenges in recent months, with limited playing time in the Premier League due to injury concerns.
Guehi, on the other hand, has maintained a high level of performance since joining Manchester City. His role as a pivotal defender in both the club’s and national team’s FA Cup triumphs has reinforced his value. Yet, Tuchel’s decision to stick with Stones and Konsa suggests a focus on proven reliability rather than risk in the early stages of the tournament. This has placed Guehi among several players on the bench, including Marcus Rashford, Bukayo Saka, and Morgan Rogers, who are also awaiting their opportunities in the World Cup.
The World Cup’s Opening Gambit
The World Cup opener against Croatia is a critical test for England, and Tuchel’s tactical choices will be scrutinized closely. The match, set for this evening, carries immense weight, as a strong performance could set the tone for the entire campaign. While Guehi’s absence may be a surprise, it highlights the manager’s emphasis on defensive cohesion and his confidence in the selected pair.
Tuchel has expressed his admiration for Stones, citing the defender’s readiness and adaptability during a recent press conference. “He is ready. He is excited to come. I am a big believer in John, he is a world class player, an amazing character, and a proven winner,” the German coach said. “He knows how to adapt to a winning culture and how to adapt tactically on the field.” These comments underscore Tuchel’s belief in Stones’ ability to thrive under pressure, despite his limited minutes in the 2024-2025 season.
Stones’ availability has been a topic of discussion, as he missed several games due to fitness issues. While he was fit for City’s final nine matches of the campaign, he was often substituted, including in the FA Cup final against Chelsea. This has led to questions about his form and consistency, but Tuchel remains optimistic about his potential. The manager emphasized that training data analysis had played a key role in his decision, with Stones’ performance metrics supporting his inclusion in the starting XI.
Guehi’s exclusion also reflects the squad’s depth and the manager’s willingness to experiment. With the World Cup being a high-stakes competition, Tuchel may prioritize players who have demonstrated their ability to perform consistently over those who have shown flashes of brilliance. This approach aligns with the broader strategy of building a balanced team capable of adapting to different opponents and scenarios.
Key Players on the Bench
While Guehi’s absence has drawn attention, he is not the only player with a bench spot. Rashford, Saka, and Rogers are also left out, raising questions about their roles in the tournament. Rashford, a key striker during Euro 2024, has faced competition for starting positions, while Saka’s inclusion in the squad has been a point of contention. Rogers, though younger, has shown promise and may be given opportunities in upcoming matches.
The decision to bench these players underscores the challenges of selecting the optimal squad for a global competition. Tuchel’s emphasis on physicality and tactical flexibility has led to a rotation of players, with some star names left to develop in the World Cup’s later stages. This approach allows the team to maintain freshness and adaptability, which could be crucial in a grueling 28-day tournament.
As the World Cup approaches, fans will be watching closely to see how these decisions unfold. The opening match against Croatia is a chance for the team to showcase its strengths and address any concerns about depth. For Guehi, the exclusion is a setback, but his talent and recent form suggest he will remain a vital part of the squad in the weeks to come.
Looking ahead, Tuchel has hinted at giving Guehi a chance to prove himself in two friendly matches before the tournament. “We will reconnect with our principles and give him the chance to play,” he said. “I believe he will have a strong tournament for us.” This statement indicates that the manager is open to adjusting his strategy, especially if the initial pairings do not deliver the desired results.
The World Cup is a unique opportunity for players to showcase their skills on the world stage, and Guehi’s situation highlights the importance of form, fitness, and tactical alignment in squad selection. As England prepares for their opener, the team’s ability to adapt and perform under pressure will be key to its success. Whether Guehi secures a starting role or continues to be a reliable substitute will depend on how the tournament unfolds and the manager’s evolving strategies.
Everything you need to know about the World Cup – England updates, the games to watch, and stories you missed – in five minutes, at 1pm, every day. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Your information will be used in line with our Privacy Policy.
ArrowMORE: Why Bukayo Saka and Marcus Rashford are on the bench for England against Croatia ArrowMORE: Why Cole Palmer, Harry Maguire, and Phil Foden are not playing for England at the World Cup
